Bahamian, Seafood · Eleuthera & Harbour Island

Seafood · Eleuthera & Harbour Island
Malcolm 51
Eleuthera & Harbour Island
A top-rated dining experience unmatched on Harbour Island, Malcolm 51 offers fine dining in both atmosphere and cuisine. With indoor or garden side seating, Malcolm 51 will leave you feeling inspired.
- Seafood
Good to know
- Address
- Pink Sands Hotel, Chapel Street, Dunmore Town, Eleuthera & Harbour Island
Menu
Prices and availability can change. Confirm with the restaurant.
Dinner MenuCurrent first-party embedded menu. A 22% service charge and 10% VAT are added by the venue.Show menuHide
AppetizersShowHide
- US$26
Butternut Squash Soup (g)
Stone Crab Salad, shaved coconut & Sweet peppers
- US$36
Dynamite Rock Shrimp
Battered Shrimp Coated With Spicy Kimchi Mayo, Crispy Seaweed Avocado & Mango Salsa
- US$42
Local Stone Crab Beignets
Apple Fennel Slaw, Horseradish Aioli
- US$31
Hamachi & Citrus Crudo (g)
Sliced Japanese Hamachi, Jalapeno Crispy Ponzu, Lime & Truffle Dressing
- US$34
Grilled Octopus (g)
Parsley, Gremolata & Squid Ink Mayo, Garden Salad
SaladsShowHide
- US$30
Char Grilled Romaine Caesar
Grilled Romaine, Cured Egg Yolk, Crispy Bacon, Pickled Shallots, Blue Cheese & Freshly Made Caesar Dressing
- US$30
Italian Burrata (g,v)
Romesco, Fennel, Concesse Tomatoes Sherry Vinaigrette
- US$28
Citrus & Fennel Salad (g,v)
Baby Beets, Orange, Blood Orange, Grapefruit, Pine Nuts, Scallions, Fennel Goats Cheese, Citrus Vinaigrette
EntréesShowHide
- US$75
Grass Fed Filet Mignon 8oz (g)
Sous Vide Beef Tenderloin, Braised Beef Cheeks, Celeriac & Black Truffle Puree, Baby Carrots, Saffron Potatoes & Red Wine Jus
- US$48
Organic Chicken Breast (g)
Sous Vide Chicken Breast, Winter Vegetables, Jerk Infused Jus
- US$57
Confit Peking Duck Leg (g)
Maple Glazed Duck Leg, Pomme Puree, Grilled Green Beans, Plums & Hoisin Sauce
- US$70
Char Grilled Lamb Chops (g)
Pomme Puree, Braised Carrots, Artichokes, Confit Tomato, Roast Garlic, Lamb Jus
- US$60
Nassau Pan Seared Grouper (g)
Avocado And Lime Crema, Toasted Coconut & Lemon Butter Sauce
- US$68
Lobster Pappardelle
Local Lobster, Pickled Jalapenos, Roasted Plum Tomatoes, Creamy Seafood Sauce & Shaved Parmigiano Reggiano
- US$72
Roasted Sea Scallops (g)
Carrot And Shallot Vinaigrette, Celeriac Puree & Fennel Salad
- US$45
Ravioli & Oyster Sauteed Mushrooms (v)
Exotic Mushroom Ravioli, Fermented Garlic, Scallions, Vegetable Nage, Brioche, Poached Organic Egg & Parmigiano Reggiano
- US$42
Vegan Tofu Thai Green Curry (g,v)
Crispy Tofu, Broccoli, Basil, Coconut Jasmine Rice & Green Papaya Salad
SidesShowHide
- US$17
Crispy Cauliflower
Worcestershire Gastrique & Lemon Zest
- US$18
Truffle Fries (g)
Fines Herbs, Grana Padano, Truffle Aioli
- US$17
Sauteed Local Organic Kale (g)
Garlic, Sambuca, Goat Cheese
- US$18
Truffle Pomme Puree (g)
Pancetta, White Cheddar, Scallions
- US$16
Charred Grilled Broccoli (g)
Tomato & Garlic Chutney
Sushi MenuCurrent first-party embedded menu.Show menuHide
SushiShowHide
- US$36
Unagi Tempura Roll (g)
BBQ Eel, Avocados, Tempura Shrimp, Eel Sauce, Sesame Seeds, Shredded Crab
- US$29
Vegan Roll (g,v)
Yamagobo, Seaweed Salad, Cucumbers, Avocados, Mangos, Toasted Coconut, Scallion Flakes
- US$45
Lobster And Avocado
Lobster, Avocados, Cream Cheese, Kani Crab, Tobiko Salad, Creamy Sriracha
- US$35
Honey Shrimp And Almonds (g)
Tempura Shrimp, Kani Crab, Sesame, Caramelized Almonds, Cream Cheese
- US$40
Wicked Blue Fin Tuna Roll (g)
Ground Tuna, Cucumbers, Ahi Tuna, Toasted Coconut Flakes, Mangos, Scallions
- US$45
Rainbow Bay Roll (g)
Tempura Soft Shell Spider Crab, Scallions, Cream Cheese, Fresh Jalapenos, Kani Crab
Sashimi Or NigiriShowHide
- US$16
2 Ahi Tuna
- US$12
2 Hamachi
- US$15
2 Blue House Salmon
- US$20
2 Scallops
- US$10
2 Ebi Shrimp
Wine MenuCurrent first-party embedded wine list. Glass and bottle prices are stored as named options.Show menuHide
CHAMPAGNE & SPARKLING WINEShowHide
101 Prosecco
Glera Prosecco Brut, Dissegna, Veneto, Italy
- Glass · US$17
- Bottle · US$75
102 Prosecco
Glera Prosecco Rose, Dissegna, Veneto, Italy
- Glass · US$18
- Bottle · US$80
103 Prosecco
Grement Brut NV, Bourgogne, France
- Bottle · US$85
104 Champagne
Moet & Chandon, Imperial Brut NV, France
- Bottle · US$195
105 Champagne
Moet & Chandon, Rose, France
- Bottle · US$220
106 Champagne
Moet & Chandon, Imperial Brut NV Split, France
- Glass · US$45
107 Champagne
Moet & Chandon, Rose, France
- Glass · US$50
108 Champagne
Veuve Clicquot, Brut Carte Jaune NV, France
- Bottle · US$325
109 Champagne
Billiecart-Salmon, Brut Reserve NV, France
- Bottle · US$250
110 Champagne
Billiecart-Salmon, Brut Rose NV, France
- Bottle · US$350
111 Champagne
Perrier-Jouet, Grand Brut NV, France
- Bottle · US$350
112 Champagne
Dom Perignon, France
- Bottle · US$650
WHITE WINEShowHide
201 MOSCATO
Giallo Goldmuskateller, DOC, Italy
- Bottle · US$95
202 Riesling,
Leon Beyer, Alsace, France
- Bottle · US$90
203 Albarino
Pazo San Mauro, Rias Baixas, Spain
- Glass · US$22
- Bottle · US$95
204 Sauvignon Blanc
Salvestrin, Napa Valley, California
- Bottle · US$165
205 Sauvignon Blanc
Sancerre Silex Blanc, Loire Valley, France
- Bottle · US$150
206 Sauvignon Blanc
Tiare, Collio, Italy
- Glass · US$25
- Bottle · US$110
207 Chardonnay
Nuiton-Beaunoy, Bourgogne, France
- Glass · US$20
- Bottle · US$85
208 Chardonnay
Migration Sta, Rita Hills, California
- Bottle · US$180
209 Chardonnay
Thierry Drouin Plaisance, Burgundy, France
- Bottle · US$160
210 Chardonnay
Chablis 1er Cru Vaucoupin, Burgundy, France
- Bottle · US$170
211 Grenache
Chateau de Beaucastel, Famille Perrin, Rhone, France
- Bottle · US$160
ROSE WINEShowHide
301 Rose
Domaine de I’lle, Cotes de Provence, France
- Bottle · US$115
302 Rose
La Vieille Ferme, Famille Perrin, VSIG, France
- Bottle · US$80
303 Rose
Minuty, Cotes de Provence, France
- Glass · US$21
- Bottle · US$90
304 Rose
Whispering Angel, Cotes de Provence, France
- Bottle · US$95
305 Rose
Domaine Delaporte Sancerre, Loire, France
- Bottle · US$135
RED WINEShowHide
401 Sangiovese
Sofia Brunello di Montalcino, Toscana, Italy
- Bottle · US$190
402 Sangiovese
Chianti Reserva DOCG Etrusca, Toscana, Italy
- Bottle · US$90
403 Barolo
Carlin de Paolo DOCG, Piemonte, Italy
- Bottle · US$170
404 Pinot Noir
Tiare Pinuar, Venezia Giulia, Italy
- Glass · US$24
- Bottle · US$100
405 Pinot Noir
Millebus Bourgogne Cote Chalonnaise, Bourgogne, France
- Bottle · US$85
406 Pinot Noir
Manuel Olivier, Morey-Saint-Denis, Bourgogne, France
- Bottle · US$240
407 Merlot
Murphy-Goode, Sonoma, CA
- Glass · US$22
- Bottle · US$95
408 Merlot
Duckhorn, Napa Valley, CA
- Bottle · US$220
409 Shiraz
- Glass · US$21
- Bottle · US$90
410 Cabernet Sauvignon
Caymus, Napa Valley, CA
- Bottle · US$400
411 Cabernet Sauvignon
Duckhorn, Napa Valley, CA
- Bottle · US$190
412 Cabernet Sauvignon
Freemark Abbey, Napa Valley, CA
- Bottle · US$225
413 Cabernet Sauvignon
Zeuss, Napa Valley, CA
- Glass · US$24
- Bottle · US$100
414 Blend
Dominus Othello, Napa Valley, CA
- Bottle · US$180
DESSERT WINEShowHide
501 Semillon
Castelnau de Suduiraut Sauternes, Bordeaux, France
- Bottle · US$175
502 Muscat
Famille Perrin, Muscat Beaumes de Venise, Rhone, France
- Glass · US$22
- Bottle · US$95
503 Amberwine
Clarendelle Semillon, Guyenne, France
- Bottle · US$150
Dessert MenuCurrent first-party embedded menu.Show menuHide
DessertsShowHide
- US$15
Caramelized Pineapple Cake
Pecan crumble, Tahitian vanilla ice cream
- US$15
Local Key Lime Curd
Charred meringue, oat almond crumble, coconut ice cream
- US$15
Sticky Toffee Cake
Aged rum caramel, Tahitian vanilla bean ice cream
- US$15
Valrhona Chocolate Crème Brulé
Almond biscotti, espresso ice cream, cacao nibs
- US$12
House Made Ice Cream & Sorbet
Assorted flavors
Before you go
From Baha Buddy's catalog · checked Oct 2026. Menus, prices and opening times change, so check with the restaurant before you go.
More places to eat in Eleuthera & Harbour Island

Cafés & bakeries · Eleuthera & Harbour Island
Bahamas Coffee Roasters
Temporarily closed4.6 (212)Rated 4.6 of 5, 212 reviews·Price level $$–$$$



